Bitter Memories of Momordica Charantia
My first three experiences with bitter melon were unpleasant. The first was before I knew anything about it and so I just tried a Thai recipe. It was inedible. The second was in a Bangladeshi restaurant in Los Angeles (New Pardes). A little better, but I didn’t finish the serving. And the third was in the form of bitter melon greens, which I added to a soup, raising the bitterness level beyond my limit.
But the bitter melon’s appealing green hue and my lack of shopping willpower at the Farmers’ Market made me try it again last weekend. This time I tried two relatively simple preparations.
I thinly sliced the vegetable in rounds (thickness of 1-2 mm), removed the large seeds that I found, then tossed it with some salt. I let it steep for 30 minutes, then rinsed the slices in cool water and put them into a drainer. At this point, the vegetable had a pleasant aroma that reminded me of apples. The salting, steeping and rinsing process is theoretically a way to remove some of the bitterness. After draining, I tossed the rounds in some vegetable oil and salt. Finally, I arranged the rounds onto a Silpat non-stick sheet and then baked them in a preheated 450 F oven for a few minutes until they were golden brown.
The results were actually good. In the first hour after the slices came out of the oven, they were nicely crisp and not excessively bitter. The flavors are subtle, but the overall impact is not—it jolted my tastebuds and left behind a mild lingering bitterness like [insert trip down memory lane here].
I sliced the bitter melon in the same way as above, but did not mix it with salt and steep it. Given salt’s propensity to remove liquid from objects, that would have led to trouble in the frying step. I heated some quite a bit of oil in a pan until it was hot enough (I’m a rookie at deep frying, and did not follow the temperature guidelines). I fried about 6 or 7 pieces at a time until they were nicely brown in the middle. However, because of the annular shape of the slices, the inside turned nicely brown before the outside was done.
The deep-fried slices were a textural disappointment, displaying crispness only on the inner edge, and a soft outer edge. But they tasted good (don’t most deep-fried things?) and the bitterness was not excessive.
Putting Bitterness Behind Me
Will I buy this vegetable again? I doubt it. The flavor of the bitter melon was pleasant enough, but overwhelmed by the cooking treatment. Furthermore, both preparations took a fair amount of time—time that I would rather be spending on other vegetables (especially this time of year).
Indexed under Ingredients, Vegetables
Technorati tags: Food : Vegetarian
Wow! You certainly gave it a fair chance! I have a couple of bitter melon recipes on my blog, if you’re interested. I don’t soak the bitter melon in salt water, as is the custom in Indian cooking because we like the bitter flavor.
This is a vegetable that requires acquired taste, Marc. It depends so much on conditioning. Here in India, we are told since our childhood how bitters are good for your health and are forced to eat the stuff. Then, as you grow up, you actucally develop a taste for it.
I encourage you to try some more recipes from Manisha’s blog. Don’t give up just yet. The karela packs in a lot of health benefits.
Oh, great new profile picture by the way. 😉
I like the first version, but sprinkled with a little turmeric and chili powder as well as salt.
There are some bitter melon curries I quite like as well – particularly those with a little sweetness to offset the bitter edge. Manisha’s blog is a great place to check out some options.
But I would say at this point you have given it a good go, and don’t need to feel guilty if you give up on it.
hahaha… bitter melon is a vegetable that creates much debate in my family. pro-bitter melon pitted against anti-bitter melon. as a staunch supporter of the anti-bitter melon side, i say that you have given it more than a fair chance. any vegetable where people have to do all sorts of silly things to it to alter the flavor is just not worth it. after all, shouldn’t we be enjoying our produce for its actual flavor? =)